Insect farming might cause more suffering than other animal farming

The edible insect market has been growing and is projected to continue increasing rapidly in the future. There has been significant research pointing to the fact that insects show signs of consciousness, and I think it’s important to seriously compare insect welfare interventions with other ones.

Brian Tomasik's “How Much Direct Suffering Is Caused by Various Animal Foods?” compares the days of suffering per kilogram of different animals. I’d like to add on to this post by a guesstimate model of where insect suffering may lie in this list. I used cricket suffering to create this model and it’s important to note there are differences in the numbers depending on which insects are being farmed—mealworms and black soldier flies likely have a different weight and sentience multiplier.

https://www.getguesstimate.com/models/21398

My reasoning for the numbers I used is given in the sheet: if you hover over the fields, you will see a detailed description.

The model shows the mean value is 1300 days of suffering per kg of insects consumed, which is twice as high as the highest animal in Brian Tomasik’s list (farmed catfish). The median value is considerably lower (35), and the 5th and 95th percentile are approximately 0.32 and 2500.

It's interesting to note that the insect sentience multiplier would have to be 10^-4 for the days of suffering / kg to be around the same as a broiler chicken.

If correct, these estimates suggest that insect welfare deserves a high priority compared to other farmed animal welfare.

Here are possible interventions. In addition to legislation to restrict insect farming (such as bans on using insect feed for livestock), I think there could be a lot of value in using insects other than crickets which have fewer neurons and therefore could have a smaller sentience multiplier (like mealworms). Interventions to ban likely more painful methods of killing insects such as boiling could also be impactful.

I’d very much appreciate discussion and feedback on the model and where you think it could be improved.

I made this model during a one-day hackathon at the Atlas Fellowship.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Overview of Shrimp Farming and Questions Surrounding it

State of Shrimp Farming The shrimp farming industry is rapidly growing at a rate of 10% a year. In light of this and new research supporting crustacean sentience, charity entrepreneurship published a report recommending a new charity working in this field. Through its incubation program, the Shrimp Welfare Project was founded. This post is based on the 80000 after hours podcast with Andres Jimenez Zorilla, founder of the Shrimp Welfare Project. The post aims to condense the information in the podcast, add new context, and raise several questions regarding shrimp farming. https://80000hours.org/after-hours-podcast/episodes/andres-jimenez-zorrilla-shrimp-welfare-project/ What does shrimp farming look like? It’s separated into different stages : Sexually active reproductive shrimp are brought to India or Vietnam Females undergo “eyestalk ablation” — the crushing of one or two eyes to induce egg laying Newly born shrimp spend 30 days growing in small tanks (incubators) Shrimp are transpo
Read more

Poor Economics: Summary and Review, Part 1

Poor Economics, is a fantastic, insightful look into the complex economics surrounding poverty. It's central thesis can be summarized in a single sentence in the foreword: "we have to abandon the habit of reducing the poor to cartoon characters and take the time to really understand their lives, in all their complexity and richness." There are many grand sweeping theories out there that claim the solution to poverty, that foreign aid is the solution to the poverty trap, or the opposite, that left to the free market with the encouragement of democracy and liberty, poverty will resolve itself. However, this fundamental question can't be resolved abstractly; it requires evidence and close examination of the economics of the poor: how they lead their lives, make decisions, and deal with problems. Because of this, a lot of Duflo's and Banerjee's theories and suggestions are backed by randomized control trials (RTCs) that aim to test out predictions with experiment
Read more

Implication of SCOTUS ruling upholding proposition 12

Image
  Background: Farming Conditions and Prop 12 Currently in the US, most breeding pigs live in factory farmers, where they are confined in gestation crates which are small metal cages so small that pigs can’t even turn around, while egg-laying hens live in tiny, cramped battery cages that cause a range of psychological and physiological harm . The crowded conditions also have potential health harms by increasing the stress levels of pigs and weakening their immune systems, which can make them more susceptible to zoonotic diseases that may spread to humans. Starting in the early 2000s, a few animal welfare groups including the Humane Society of the Unites States aimed to ban the farming system of cages for hens, breeding pigs and veal calves. In 2008, Proposition 2 was passed which put in place a “production” ban on cages, which said that producers had to ensure pigs, hens, and calves could lie down, turn around, and extend their limbs or wings without hitting the side of an enclosur
Read more